• Handcrafted

    Whatever jewelry piece you have in mind, we can undertake any custom design and realize it with utmost care and precision.

  • Free Shipping

    Enjoy free domestic shipping on every order, complete with insurance for full peace of mind, from our store straight to your door.

  • Expert Guidance

    We’re here to help — chat with us online, call or text, or schedule a virtual or in-store appointment with our jewelry experts.

  • 30 Day Returns

    Don't absolutely love your item? Return it to us - 30 day window online, or 20 days in-store. Excludes special orders.

Buy now, pay later.

Engagement Rings

Planning to propose?

Let Ben Garelick make it unforgettable.

Shop Now

Necklaces & Pendants

Find your perfect necklace - start with a chain and top it off with a touch of diamond sparkle.

Shop Now

Bestsellers

Crafted to shine with any outfit, for any moment - our bestselling jewelry is made to match your unique style.

Shop Now

Custom Design

For those with the highest standards and unique visions, we offer a bespoke design service. Whether reimagining a cherished heirloom, creating a one-of-a-king engagement ring, or bringing a personal inspiration to life, our artisans will guide you every step of the way.

From sketch to polish, we blend expert craftsmanship with the finest materials to ensure your creation is extraordinary, an enduring piece as personal as it is beautiful.

Get Your Custom Ring

Fine Jewelry

Crafted from the finest silver, gold and platinum, our fine jewelry combines exceptional quality with timeless design.

Every piece is made with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring beauty, durability and elegance that will be cherished for a lifetime.

Shop Fine Jewelry

Rated 5 / 5 in 1270 Reviews

What Our Customers Have To Say

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

“I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!”

Madelyn Rossi

Patti and Peter were so helpful while I was looking for an engagement ring. They answered all of my questions along the way and didn’t try to pressure me at any point in the process. My fiancé loves her ring and I highly recommend Ben Garelick Jewelers.

Jacob Warden

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Jackie Haas-Anglen

I had the best experience finding my engagement ring with Susan at Ben Garelick. I had visited several jewellers, but her honesty and patience stood out. She listened carefully and made sure I found exactly what I wanted. The store was welcoming and never felt pushy, which made the process easy and enjoyable. Susan even arranged to bring in pieces I wanted to see. Thank you, Susan and the Ben Garelick team, for making such an important decision feel so special. I could not be happier!

Tyler Manthey

Received my new tantalum wedding band today and I have to say it is stunning. The ring is so unique and was worth the wait while Ben Garelick Jewelers custom ordered it for me. Their communications about status from order to receipt were top notch.

Jon Hanson

Buying my ring from Ben Garelick was an incredible experience. Peter Manka Jr. handled everything with great care and professionalism. The communication was excellent, and the custom piece arrived in the UK even faster than promised. Peter made the whole process smooth and stress-free, and the result was perfect. I am so grateful for his help and attention to detail. Thank you, Peter and the Ben Garelick team, for such a wonderful experience. I absolutely love my ring!

Sorin

Follow Our Socials

@bengarelickjewelers

Our Store

For more than 70 years, Ben Garelick Jewelers has helped thousands of clients make holidays, weddings, birthdays and anniversaries extra special.

We pride ourselves on delivering reliable and consistent quality jewelry, service and repairs.

Experience this and a tremendous selection of uinique dimaond engagement rings and more at our store location on Transit Road in Williamsville, NY!

Book An In-Person Visit Book A Virtual Appointment